Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Landsknecht Voran!

 


I watched Radu Jude's outstanding I Do Not Care If We Go Down in History as Barbarians recently and, as it was meant to, it got me thinking about historical memory, national identity, and how we distort or forget the past. I have since thought a bunch about how tempting it was at the end, even for me (somebody who studied history and thinks of himself as well informed and highly critical of the United States), to shake my head at what a fucked-up country Romania is and how collectively delusional Romanians have chosen to be about their past—to think, “Well, my country might be a mess, but at least we're not that much of a mess.” But we are, of course. We're worse, in many ways! We have our own misremembered and elided atrocities and genocides, and we continue to deliberately misunderstand ourselves and our role in the world, even as we reckon with the particularly brazen criminality of the current administration.

But, ever distractible, I've also undertaken a mostly unrelated little journey of research and reflection. There's an interstitial moment in the film, not obviously connected to the scenes preceding and following, in which Ioana Iacob, or her character (or both of them; they're deliberately blurred together) listens to some German folk music. You'd think she was, in the course of her research, listening to something out of the Nazi songbook, but the lyrics (half-grasped with my rusty old German) struck me as too melancholic and anti-war to be Nazi music. I looked up some phrases from the song and identified it: “Wildgänse rauschen durch die Nacht,” a poem written by a German soldier in the spring of 1915 and set to music a year later. Huddled in a trench in a blasted French forest, the poet watches geese flying north for the summer and wonders whether, by the time they fly south again for the winter, he and his comrades will be dead. (He survived the year, and France, but died on the Eastern Front in 1917.)

The most popular (or at least most accessible) version of the song was recorded in the 1960s by the Botho-Lucas-Chor for the album Die Landsknechtstrommel (The Landsknecht Drum—literally an old type of tenor drum used by landsknechts), so of course I had to listen to the whole album, curious about what this music was and how a mournful poem about the fighting in France in 1915 got to be associated with Renaissance-era military history. Unsurprisingly, as when you poke into pretty much any corner of German history, I found a whole lot of distortion, fabrication, and Nazi bullshit.

* * * 

The average reader of this blog probably knows exactly who the landsknechts were, but just in case: They were German mercenary troops (specifically, mercenaries raised from German-speaking regions of the Holy Roman Empire), modeled after the Swiss Reisläufer, and active from the late 15th to the early 17th centuries. Not that long a period, in the big scheme of things, particularly compared to their Swiss counterparts, but they have an outsized place in the German cultural imagination; they were colorful, literally and figuratively, they were involved in many of the most important campaigns of the 16th century, and they faded from the historical stage just as the horrifying Thirty Years' War was destroying Germany, so they came to represent something of a lost golden age. (Similarly, maybe, to how the Arthurian legends loom large in the imagined golden age of pre-Norman Britain, albeit a more immediate and acute phenomenon.)

The whole category of “Landsknechtslieder” encompasses a lot more than actual songs sung by 16th-century landsknechts. The vast majority are not historical, but were composed in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and many only resemble actual Landsknechtslieder in form, with lyrics related to the Great War, to the Wandervogel movement, to interwar politics, or to other periods of German history.

I'm not going to survey the whole corpus (at least not until I decide to get a PhD and write a dissertation about this stuff) but will just look at the contents of that enduringly popular Botho-Lucas-Chor album. Organizing the songs chronologically, as best we can (shout out to www.volksliederarchiv.de for being an invaluable resource here and for putting a lot of these songs in their proper historical and political context), we can trace the genre's evolution, and the popular German understanding of the landsknecht as a historical or symbolic figure with it.

* * * 

We start in the 16th century, with a handful of songs known (“Wir zogen in das Feld,” “Unser liebe Fraue”) or believed (“Wer war es der den Lorbeer brach,” “Die Bauern wollten freie sein”) to actually date back to the period when landsknechts were active. All of these have been modified and amended in the form we hear on Die Landsknechtstrommel—only the first verse of “Unser liebe Fraue,” for instance, existed in the version published in 1556, and the arrangements have all had a bunch of modern bells and whistles slapped on. There's a clear through-line in all the lyrics here, which is that the experience of being a 16th-century mercenary is mostly miserable. Most of “Wir zogen in das Feld” is a litany of suffering: a verse about poverty, another about hunger, another about disease. “Wer war es der den Lorbeer brach,” heavy with religious themes and language, marvels numbly at the slaughter of thousands of soldiers in a matter of hours. “Die Bauern wollten freie sein” is about the German Peasants' War (more on that later), but from the perspective of the mercenaries who helped put the peasant revolution down (and suffered terrible casualties to do so). The beautiful “Unser liebe Fraue” is a prayer to the Virgin Mary (these are the slightly archaic original 1556 lyrics):

Unser liebe fraue vom kalten Brunnen,
bescher uns armen Landsknecht ein warme Sunnen
das wir nit erfriren!
Wol in des wirtes hauß
trag wir ein vollen seckel
und ein leren wider auß.

Our Lady of the Cold Well,
grant us poor landsknechts a warm sun
so we don't freeze!
Into the tavern
we carry a full purse
and an empty one out again.

Then centuries pass, and the landsknechts fade into hazy, rose-colored memory. When we pick up the thread again, it's the late 19th century, after the unification of the German Empire, and the mood is totally unrecognizable. In “Vom Barette schwankt die Feder” (1893), we get “Landsknechtleben, lustig Leben”—the landsknecht's life is a fun one! “Wir traben in die Weite” doesn't pretend to be a Landsknechtslied (its ostensible theme is cavalry warfare), but here it is on an album of “Landsknechtslieder” and the mood, now at the very start of the war in 1914, remains triumphant, celebrating the invasion of France: “Ins Feindesland zu reiten / Hurra, Viktoria! /Fürs Vaterland zu streite” (“to ride into enemy territory / hurrah, Victoria! / for the fatherland to fight”).

Predictably, the mood sours. During the war, we get “Der Tod reitet auf einem kohlschwarzen Rappen” ("Death Rides a Coal-Black Steed"), aka “Flanders in Not” (“Flanders in Distress”), a pseudo-historical tune obviously referring to current events. In the 1920s, the genre branches out in several different directions, and becomes popular both among the Wandervogel (a neo-Romantic, German nationalist youth movement, which played a big role in popularizing German folk music but also incubated a lot of proto-Nazi ideas) and among paramilitaries on the left and right. So we see wistful or ironic reflections on the recent Great War, as in “Wildgänse rauschen durch die Nacht” and in new verses for “Unser liebe Fraue,” which like “Der Tod reitet…” refer to the invasion of Belgium: “Wir schlucken Staub beim Wandern…der Kaiser schluckt ganz Flandern” (“We swallow dust on the march…the emperor swallows all of Flanders”); we also get more political content. Some of this is extremely nebulous: “Und wenn wir marschieren” (1922) and the later “Die Trommel schlägt und schmettert” (1934) are full of abstract imagery of the glorious future, promising “after the storm” a “new land of action” or that “the new era comes tomorrow.” Others make very explicit reference to historical events. There are a couple lionizing Catholic generals of the Thirty Years' War (the 1927 “Trum trum die Landsknecht ziehn im Land herum” seems to play it straight in praise of Wallenstein; 1922's “Es schlägt ein fremder Fink im Land” ostensibly praises Tilly but strikes me as subtextually anti-Catholic, being from the perspective of a thuggish Catholic soldier), and there are a couple more about the German Peasants' War, this time taking the peasants' side: “Die Glocken stürmten vom Bernwardsturm” (1923) and “Wir sind des Geyers schwarzer Haufen” (1920-ish).

The latter is famous (or infamous) for having been claimed by the Nazis and the Communists alike—it was part of the NSDAP songbook during their rule, and it was part of the GDR songbook after the war. Florian Geyer is a fascinating figure, a nobleman who threw in with the peasants and lead the rebel army's only troop of heavy cavalry in a doomed effort to throw down the nobility and the Church (and his surname basically means “vulture,” which would be too on-the-nose if he were a fictional bad guy). The song exists in various different versions, including ones with a slightly different title, “Wir sind des Geyers schwarzen Haufen,” which draws a line between Geyer's troops and the “Schwarze Reichswehr” (far-right paramilitaries connected to the official military of the Weimar Republic). Geyer's troop was the singular “Black Company” or “Black Host”; pluralizing it suggests the multiple Freikorps of the early Weimar years.

In the Nazi era, the prewar trend of imagining the landsknecht's life as a jolly one ominously returns—in “Das Kalbfell klingt” (1930), the singer doesn't just have a merry time with his girl, but threatens to have some violent fun with the French “the Landsknecht way”—but is joined, and then superseded, by a sort of devil-may-care machismo, wherein the landsknecht's life is fun when he's spending his loot in camp, but is more importantly manfully reckless and violent. Gambling imagery suddenly appears everywhere, as in the almost explicitly Nazi “Das Leben ist ein Würfelspiel” (1935), whose title is literally “Life is a Game of Dice,” and the rollicking “Weit lasst die Fahnen wehen” (written 1917, but widely published in 1941). It's a banger, but it's easy to see why it ended up irremediably tainted by association with Nazism:

Die Reihen fest geschlossen
Und vorwärts unverdrossen
Falle, wer fallen mag
Kann er nicht mit uns laufen
So mag er sich verschnaufen
Bis an den jüngsten Tag

Close the ranks tightly
And go forward, undaunted
Let him fall who may fall
If he can't keep pace with us
He can catch his breath
Until Judgment Day

You can almost hear the panzergrenadiers belting this one out as they rolled into Belarus, right? There's a dash of social Darwinism here, and of course there's a heaping helping of the kind of tough-guy bullshit that has motivated young men to go to war since time immemorial, but there's also a curious (and yet totally apt) amorality. Nothing about the great German nation, or righting history's wrongs, or the glorious new dawn or anything like that. We've come all the way full circle to a kind of anti-romanticism about the landsknechts, who were, after all, mercenaries. It's war for war's sake, for filthy lucre and to test oneself, nothing more.

* * * 

One of the things that's most striking about all of this is how strongly all of these songs, in all their different modes, from all their different eras, center the common soldier. Even the few that lionize aristocrats like Tilly, Wallenstein, and Geyer (or purport to, anyway) set those figures at some distance and are about commoners in their service. The landsknecht is, at least from my Anglo-American perspective, an unusual figure to have become a romantic sort of folk hero, for good and ill.

In the British tradition (pre-Norman and Anglo-Norman alike), the archetypal hero is the knight: noble, chivalrous, solitary or accompanied by a few sworn companions. And that's not just true of Britain; it extends to the Normans' French cousins, and to a great extent to Spain, and even to some of the heroic traditions of the supposedly more egalitarian Americas and Scandinavia, from gaucho to cowboy to viking. Yeah, the latter aren't sir-so-and-so, but we've assimilated them into the chivalric heroic tradition; the cowboy has his code of honor and is a lone gunman, or has a small posse; the viking sails off into the unknown with a few bosom companions (and a bunch of thralls, but we can shuffle them out of frame like we do the knight's grooms and squires).

It's true of Japan, too, which has its own heroic quasi-chivalric tradition of noble knighthood, and whose media have become an almost equally important source (to Anglo-American media) of romanticized or fantasy-inflected versions of the historic past, both drawing on Japan's own history and folklore and increasingly featuring second- and third-order interpretations of Western European history, often playing on Western fantasy tropes that in turn drew on actual history or folklore.

The landsknecht is a starkly different figure from the knight. No code of honor, no noble lineage, just a guy doing a shitty job. Not exceptionally skilled, either; he's one soldier among hundreds or thousands of others (and the tactics of the landsknechts particularly emphasis coordination over individual heroics). His identity has been much exploited and abused by some of the worst political actors in German history, but I think there's something worth reclaiming there, especially for (look, I finally brought it back to the notional subject of this blog) tabletop gaming. The landsknecht is much more in the spirit of the OSR than any knight could ever be!

 

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Everybody Wants Some: Companions and Romance in BG3



Following up, belatedly, on my first post about BG3. (I'm traveling, I'm working from a friend's dining room table on my decrepit old MacBook, everything is slower and more difficult than I expect. The formatting is probably all janky. I'll fix it. And I'll get back to the twice-a-week thing, I swear it.) Today, we're doing the NPCs.
 
* * *
Writing about BG3’s characters primarily means writing about the companions, and given that nearly all of the companions are romanceable, writing about the companions inevitably means writing about the romances, so first things first: Let’s get my feelings about videogame romances (and TTRPG romances, for that matter) on the table. I don’t care for them!
As I’ve alluded to here before, my preference in tabletop games is to keep sex and romance lightweight, limited to NPCs, and generally “off-screen.” Yes, it’s fun for some players and it’s important for some characters, and I want to accommodate that, but it’s potentially super uncomfortable (especially if multiple PCs are involved, whether that’s because two players want their characters to get together or because two PCs want to pursue the same NPC) and it’s almost always going to involve one person pulling focus in a way that can be boring for others. I’ll have some more thoughts on that last bit later; generally, that’s less of a concern in a singleplayer videogame, where the player is free to lavish all the time in the world on whatever sidequest or other peculiar fixation they like.
But I still don’t really care for game romances, and that’s because I think they tend not to be all that convincing or enjoyable. That’s for many of the same reasons the main storylines of these games tend not to be great, and I’m sympathetic for the same reasons. I mentioned in the previous post understanding developers who recognize that most players aren’t going to finish their game at all and that most who do aren’t going to take evil (or otherwise unconventional) routes to the ending; why throw a ton of development resources at something only a small fraction of people are ever going to see? Companion romances offer a similar dilemma. Lots of players aren’t going to do all the companions’ personal quests; fewer still are going to do any given romance. This means the team needs to economize. Even if romances are a big draw for players, each individual romance is a lot of work for relatively little return in playtime.
One good way to economize is to offer only a small number of romances, but this has obvious downsides and tends to provoke a lot of griping from players. Another way to economize is to make every romanceable characters “MCsexual,” as they say; this is the route BG3 takes. Again, I get it. It’s a sensible move in terms of husbanding development resources, and it plays well with a lot of fans. That said, I really dislike it from the perspective of writing, character development, and what we might call my principles about how we engage with media and how media should approach its audience.
The first point is simpler to explain: Erasing the characters’ sexuality—which is what this choice does for most of the BG3 companions more than it renders implicitly pansexual or bisexual—flattens them. It takes away an important facet of human (or demihuman) identity, takes away their history, makes each one less distinct from the others. It contributes to a frustrating pattern of in-game behavior (if you’re just nice to everybody in the early going, pretty soon all of them are trying to fuck you all at the same time, gumming up every evening spent at camp with a janky queue of romantic overtures), but worse, I think, it encourages unpleasant extra-diegetic behavior. It makes these characters less people and more a menu of sexual options, flavors to try on as part of the player’s character customization, little different from class, race, and the like. There’s something pornographic about it, the idea that all these people exist to be bedded, and that each one is ready to go the moment the PC expresses interest.
Maybe a lighthearted videogame isn’t the right place to learn important life lessons, but people do seem to take a lot from these games, and BG3 in particular, when it comes to modeling the relationships they want and picturing their ideal partners. And “she’s just not into you” is a very important lesson for people to learn. Realizing that nearly every BG3 companion was a romance option made me think, wistfully, of Cyberpunk 2077, which famously offered one and only one romanceable companion to straight male PCs: the tall, loudmouthed, hotheaded, and generally just not traditionally feminine Panam Palmer. A lot of guys hated this! They didn’t want Panam; they wanted the petite, girlish, relatively demure Judy Alvarez…who’s gay. Years of teeth-gnashing and ethically dubious modding later, the devs have never caved to fan pressure; Judy remains stubbornly sapphic. And sure, a lot of the guys who hated that they couldn’t “romance” her as a male character learned nothing from the experience (many just modded the game so they could), but hopefully a few learned something.
I recognize that a lot of people do not need to learn this lesson. Many people are reminded frequently, and often unkindly, that the world doesn’t consider them sexually or romantically desirable. It’s cool to have a game where everybody is an option for them, and maybe that positive experience for them is worth reinforcing a bunch of straight boys’ bad, unexamined ideas. Nobody more acutely needs to learn that the world is not a menu of sexual conquests for them to select from than straight men, and straight men still probably represent a plurality of the audience of most games, including BG3. But maybe we don’t need every game to cater to that dominant group, even if it’s a negative, chastising form of catering.
I don’t know. I just know that I, personally, don’t really care for this approach. But I still enjoyed the game, and I still romanced Shadowheart, so who cares what I think? All of this is essentially a very long preamble to me acknowledging that, yeah, you learn a lot about these characters through the romance dialogue, and I’ve only played once and romanced one, and although I will probably play again and am certainly curious about some of the others (Astarion, Karlach) I’m never going to see them all, which curtails my appreciation of some. It’s my understanding that Halsin, for instance, remains pretty opaque to any PC who doesn’t romance him. Alas, I will not be romancing Halsin. C’est la vie.
With that caveat in place, from my limited perspective, my verdict is that the companions are a mixed bag but generally pretty strong. They represent a range of ways to develop a character, some more successful than others but all viable, and all worth thinking about in a TTRPG context.
* * * 
Lae'zel, to start with the first companion we meet, is a character almost entirely defined by her (D&D) race and class. She's a githyanki fighter. That's it. Nothing special in her backstory, in her parentage or childhood or upbringing, no special destiny. She's an archetypal githyanki fighter. And it works! She's a great character, brings an interesting perspective to the party's adventures on the Sword Coast, and has a whole satisfying story arc of her own. The big choice she faces doesn't involve any challenge to her core identity or her values. Even if she chooses revolution, she remains a soldier, and she remains utterly dedicated to the githyanki people. She just rallies to a new standard.
Astarion represents an almost diametrically opposed approach. His race and class are almost entirely irrelevant to his character; he's defined entirely by his history, his relationship with Cazador (and the other spawn, and their victims), his self-image and self-esteem. This also works! He's a great character, maybe the best of the bunch.
Shadowheart's kind of a synthesis of those two. “Cleric of Shar” is pretty much her whole identity…in her own mind. Like Astarion, though, hers is a story of abuse and indoctrination, willing but not consensual service to an evil cause, and paying her abuse forward. Like Lae'zel, she comes to a point where she has to choose whether to affirm her allegiance to the cause she's known all her life or turn against it; unlike Lae’zel, rejecting her upbringing also means changing her personality and her values (or, seen another way, recognizing and resolving the tensions between the values she was taught and her instinct for empathy, for kindness to children and animals, etc.).
I know that Gale and Wyll were also in the early access build of the game, but I don't think it's coincidental that Lae'zel and Shadowheart are guaranteed to be the first two companions the player meets and Astarion likely to be the third; I'd wager that those three were in development the longest. Gale and Wyll are relatively underdeveloped, as is Karlach (who was definitely the last addition).
Gale is a solid character, has some fun dialogue, and brings some fun banter to party interactions, but is perhaps the least connected of any of the companions to the others or to the game’s main story. His arc ends up being something of a cautionary tale, for the tabletop GM, of what can happen if you let a player’s melodramatic romance with an important NPC take on too much of a life of its own. He loved a goddess! He betrayed her! She punished him, or did she? It’s interesting stuff, but (unlike with Astarion’s story, which is also disconnected from the main plot) it doesn’t really offer anything for the PC or the other companions to do. Its dramatic climax involves Gale just going away for a minute to have a big talk off-screen. Thrilling stuff! (Or its dramatic climax involves Gale blowing everybody up, but the game essentially scolds you for having made a bad, anti-canon choice if you try that.)
Wyll, as I understand it, underwent a pretty significant rewrite, softening him and making his arc more straightforwardly (if mildly tragically) heroic. It’s fine. It gets the job done. His connection to and various bonds with Karlach and some of the important non-party NPCs in the city keep him involved in a way Gale isn’t, but his generic good-guy personality leaves a lot to be desired.
Karlach's an interesting one. Fun, endearing, feels a bit unfinished. The zaniest character, in the sense that she often comes close to breaking the fourth wall, lampshading things with comments about tragic backstories and the like. She has a bunch of dialogue that doesn't really fit the setting—at one point, she makes two cinema references back to back, in a world that doesn't have cinema (and not just in throwaway dialogue, either, but at the dramatic climax of her story)—and I can't quite make up my mind about whether it's simply lazy writing or whether there's something winking about it, like she's an MCU character who wandered into a different media franchise by accident. It sort of works, somehow? Her whole story is like a caricature of a protagonist's tortured background. Impressionable waif taken in by predatory older man, literally sold to a devil and taken to actual Hell where her heart was literally ripped out, etc. It might land a little more effectively if some of the tropes it's sending up weren't right there in the room with it, so to speak. (Pretty silly that two of the six origin companions have tragic backstories that involve dangerous devices being implanted in their chests.) Which I suppose is strong evidence in favor of the argument that, no, it's not a sendup, it's just a pack of cliches. But they’re fun cliches, at least.
* * *
Looking at all six origin companions together, I see two interesting things. One is that the first three—my favorite three!—are straightforwardly bad guys, in the sense that they (a githyanki warrior, a cleric of Shar, and a vampire spawn) are classic mid-level Forgotten Realms enemy types. The others aren't straight out of the Monster Manual, but they're not far off: the mad wizard whose ambition outstrips his morality, the fame-hungry egotist who sold his soul for power (albeit the devs walked this one back in the final release), the footsoldier of an infernal army. Thinking back on the wild profusion of recruitable companions of all alignments in BG1 and BG2, it’s hard not to suspect that Larian had planned for a much larger group of potential companions, started with the evil (or at least evil-ish) ones, and then scaled back and found themselves having to dial back the evilness. Ah, what could have been!
The other is that there are a bunch of doublings going on here. Astarion and Shadowheart as abuse victims abusing others in turn. Shadowheart and Karlach as abducted children. Karlach and Wyll shanghaied into the Blood War. Gale and Astarion both seeking magical apotheosis. Gale and Karlach both with IEDs in their chests. Lae’zel and Shadowheart reckoning with cult upbringings. Hard not to feel like the devs could’ve done more with this, too, although this might be something I’ve missed out on by not playing as any of the origin companions. So many opportunities for these characters to bond, to find points of identification with one another, or to fall into conflict over the narcissism of small differences. We get a bit of that with Shadowheart and Lae’zel, but it peters out quickly.
Finally, of course, there are four other, later-arriving companions. As I alluded to above, I don’t have much to say about Halsin, who strikes me as a rather generic bear and druid, thought I realize I hardly scratched his surface. I have nothing at all say about Minthara, whom I killed not realizing she was recruitable. Oops!
Jaheira and Minsc, though? Loved them. Huge credit to the writers who worked on both for serving up successful nostalgic fan service for us old Infinity Engine heads (and even cracking a few jokes about it via Karlach’s in-game fangirling) while actually making both characters suit this story and these roles. I think Minsc might be the more impressive feat—keeping all of the wackiness that defines what is essentially a joke character while giving him an interesting story relevant to the plot, not letting the silliness damage the setting’s verisimilitude (such as it is on the goofy old Sword Coast), and even injecting some real pathos into the proceedings—but I just loved Jaheira. Maybe it’s because I’m an old fart myself, at least relative to what I was when Jaheira and I first traveled together, but I found her perspective endlessly compelling. Also, I want her house. Especially her office. Especially her office’s secret annex.
Next up: BG3's reputation as the highest and best representation of tabletop D&D in videogame form. Maybe. Probably.

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

I Finally Played Baldur's Gate 3


I grew up on the old Black Isle and BioWare (and Troika, Obsidian, etc.) games, and the original Baldur's Gate was a particular favorite of mine—I still vividly remember the first time I played, meeting Imoen, exploring Candlekeep. I think I held off on playing BG3 this long mostly just because it was such a daunting undertaking for somebody with a full-time job and a bunch of other hobbies, but perhaps I also had some apprehension that it wouldn't live up to a bunch of hazy, rose-colored teenage memories.

And, of course, nothing really can (I probably won't ever play the BG1 and BG2 remasters, because I know they wouldn't hold up to my memories), but BG3 came a lot closer than I expected—much closer than the disappointing Pillars of Eternity or the good-not-great Torment: Tides of Numenera had. Absorbing and engrossing almost all the way through, with as many moments of really transcendent excellence, right up there with some of the best CRPGs I've played, as it had moments of jarring narrative failure or mechanical frustration. Having enjoyed it so much, and having just sunk more than a hundred hours of my time into it over the course of the past couple months, I'm boiling over with thoughts about the game, the writing, its influence on tabletop D&D, the state of the hoary old Forgotten Realms, and more. Check out that ominous new label. Get ready for a couple weeks of BG3 posting!

* * *

Let's start with the game itself, and let's start at the ending. I know I'm not literally the last person in the world to play the game, even if it feels like it, so fair warning: Many spoilers follow.

I won't belabor this—other people have written novel-length Reddit posts about it already—but the conclusion, at least of the “good” branches of the plot, is a disaster, full of gaping plot holes (why is Orpheus able to turn into a mind flayer at will?), jarringly absent conversation choices (the Emperor just turns traitor, without even a DC 30 check to change his mind; Lae'zel doesn't offer to sacrifice herself for Orpheus; nobody really makes any effort to talk the PC out of any number of quasi-suicidal or literally suicidal options; etc.), and lore handwaving to justify narrative railroading (oops, only an illithid can do this), not to mention a bunch of side plots fizzling out where the development team clearly just ran out of time and resources (e.g., the whole thing about Karlach's heart, Dammon, infernal metal, the Steel Watchers, etc.). It's sloppy, it's disappointing, it's easily the worst thing about the game…but I don't really mind it that much.

A game's gotta end somewhere, both narratively (in a sense, any hard stop to an enjoyable and immersive story is going to be disappointing) and technically. Development resources aren't unlimited. And a clunky, abrupt ending like this with a bunch of seams showing just seems to be par for the course for games as big and otherwise open as BG3. You can't build a mechanically satisfying and economical conclusion that wraps up dozens of different threads of player choices. You're already committing a bunch of resources to evil and otherwise “bad” endings that most players will never see (and of course, given the way people engage with videogames these days, you know that most players aren't going to make it to any of the endings); you literally can't afford to offer a hundred different paths a hundred different bespoke endings. So you just collapse most of your narrative threads back down to a single decision point and give everybody the same handful of options. Turns out only a mind flayer can operate the MacGuffin, please use the one mind flayer we have handy or choose from this very small menu of characters who can, abruptly and with barely any protest from any of the other characters, turn into one. It sucks, but it sucks in a familiar and understandable way.

And the thing is, not only am I accustomed to videogames having to make these bargains for the same of economy, I'm just not invested enough in the main story to be all that put out by it. This side of things is a problem that isn't unique to games: Save-the-world narratives pretty much always fall flat. I'd love for popular media in general to knock it off with these stories, and videogames in particular should, knowing how their players are going to behave, turn 180 degrees away from the urgent and the epic to embrace the picaresque. You know the player is going to want to touch everything and talk to everybody and peer into every nook and cranny. Don't fight it. Make smaller-scale narratives where the protagonist is a bumbling idiot. Be more like my beloved Disco Elysium, a game so lackadaisically paced that it sometimes forces you to read a book or sit on a bench or internalize your thoughts before the clock will advance enough for something to happen.

But BG3, of course, is not, and cannot be, a picaresque. It's goofball epic fantasy, and epic fantasy is going to have a dumb save-the-world plot you don't really care about, and the ending probably isn't going to be very satisfying, and that's okay. So let's return to the beginning. I actually bounced off the game at first (I've owned it for more than a year, but only got properly stuck into it a couple months ago), and the sheer goofball derangement of the Forgotten Realms was a big part of why.

Like I said, I grew up on a bunch of old CRPGs set in the Forgotten Realms, and I read novels set in the Forgotten Realms, and then, as the saying goes, when I became a man, I put away childish things. I had long filed the whole setting away in my mental library as “kid stuff,” a view reinforced by my much more recent engagement with the OSR-o-sphere and its deeply entrenched contempt for “kitchen-sink fantasy.” (Not to mention the long-overdue reassessment of many corners of the Realms, from Chult to Kara-tur, as being probably irredeemably racist.) Unlike, say, the recent D&D movie (which I quite enjoyed), BG3 does not ease its audience into the gonzo looniness of the setting. Right from the jump, we've got dragon-riding githyanki attacking an illithid nautiloid. In Hell. It's ridiculous. It was not, for me, a compelling hook.

But I persisted, eventually, and although I will never be able to take illithids seriously (the final boss of this game is just the Big Brain from Futurama, for Christ's sake), I did develop first a grudging appreciation for the tadpoles as a narrative device and then an ungrudging appreciation for the writing of the Absolutists and the mind flayer characters, particularly the Emperor. The tadpole situation is a much better excuse to bring the main party members together, and bind them to each other, than we usually get from games like these. It gives the player a narratively coherent reason to team up with people like Astarion and Lae'zel whom a reasonable person might otherwise be inclined to fight or leave at the roadside (but for the nagging thought that this is obviously a major character and abandoning them would mean missing lots of game content). And the Absolute offers a strong justification for, and puts a clever spin on, a bunch of bad guys joining forces. The writers could've made a bit more of it, but I liked the few observations that characters made about how diverse the Absolute's army was, with humans, goblins, drow, and all manner of others working together for a common purpose. Makes a fun contrast to the plight of the tiefling refugees! (Should the game have done more with that angle than have Zevlor briefly tempted by the Absolute? Yes. But even the suggestion of it was fun and provocative.)

And the mind flayers! Omeluum is fun, and a great kind of amuse-bouche for the Emperor's big reveal. The latter is an outstanding character, and I find the philosophical questions raised by him, and interactions with him, even more interesting here in 2026 than they probably were when the game first released. The Emperor is, in a lot of ways, a model for artificial general intelligence. He is fundamentally unlike other minds (and does not have a soul, or at least not in the way that humanoid characters do) but does a creditable job imitating them and interacting with them on their level. He has literally digested a human mental corpus, not to mention figuratively digesting an enormous amount of information about humanoids from books and first-person observation. He tailors his appearance, his personality, and his apparent values to appeal to his interlocutor, to seem “human,” to seem like a trustworthy ally. It's all an act, it's all instrumental, but it's so authentic-seeming that it's hard to say where the act ends and the real Emperor begins. Is there anything beneath the mask? (And it's authentic-seeming both diegetically and extra-diegetically, by which I mean that, within the fiction, he seems genuine, and as a player of the game, the way he's written is no less convincing than the way any of the humanoid companions are.) Is he trustworthy? Is he human, or close enough to be treated like anybody else? Clunky heel turn at the very end notwithstanding, the game doesn't ever come down clearly on one side or the other. Great stuff.

Much of the main plot, especially from the middle of Act 2 onward, does exemplify a lot of the worst qualities of “cinematic,” railroaded RPG storytelling. Oh, there's the duke we've been looking for. Can we just jump in and rescue him now? No, two of these guys are bosses in the next chapter and you're not strong enough to fight all these guys at once, so you just have to stand here and watch as two of them leave. Then you get to fight one of them; he's the big boss for this chapter. Cool.

But like I said, pleasant surprises in the writing of the Absolutists and mind flayers aside, I wasn't in it for the main story. The side quests are always the best bits, and that's as true as ever here. Some of my favorite parts of the game were companion quests, which I'll get to in a subsequent post (this is long enough already), but there were a bunch of others I loved—the cursed Thorms, the murder mystery, the haunted mansion, the wizard's tower, all of the hag shenanigans, and perhaps above all the House of Hope. And quite apart from the specific plots of the side quests, I was just in heaven around the middle of Act 3, with the whole Lower City open to explore. One of the best urban environments in a game, maybe the best I've ever seen in a top-down RPG like this (and yes, that includes Revachol…maybe). So vibrant, so real-feeling. Would I love to spend a whole game just wandering around a city like that, barging into people's living rooms, rooting around in mausolea, robbing banks, exorcising ghosts? Yes. This wasn't a whole game, but it was pretty damn good.

* * * 

Next up: the companions. And the implementation of the 5e rules, plus the idea that this is “the best videogame representation of tabletop roleplaying ever.” And some thoughts about our dear benighted Forgotten Realms. October is BG3 month, I guess!

Thursday, October 1, 2026

A Contemptible Struggle

 


Time for another depressing one that has nothing to do with games. Sorry!

Thing is, I’ve been thinking about the Cornell case a lot this week. In addition to thinking about the crime itself, and the environment that produced it, and our benighted political and cultural climate, I keep thinking things like, Well, who cares what I think? I’m a nobody, and does anybody really need another man to weigh in on this right now? But there is one aspect of this that I do need to push myself to write about, and even if my tiny platform only reaches a dozen men, some of those men probably need to hear it. We mustn’t fall into the trap of assuming that all of our friends, everybody who’s “like us” in some cultural sense (has the same hobbies, the same interests) shares our values and knows what we know.

* * *

If somebody I’m close to—a friend, a cousin, a friend’s kid, whatever—were accused of a heinous crime like this, I think, to be truly honest, that I would reflexively reach for exculpatory explanations. I would have, deep in the pit of my stomach, the fear that the accusations were true, but I suspect that that fear would only strengthen my desire to explain, to rationalize, to excuse. I would not reach for explicit victim-blaming, knowing how vanishingly rare false accusations are, but I expect that I would grasp for an explanation along the lines of “This must have been a misunderstanding.” There must be more to this story. I know him, and he wouldn’t do that.

Again, though, that’s if the accused were someone close to me. One of the things I find most sordid, depressing, and alarming about this story is how many men, including quite a few men with large platforms, men in positions of authority or credibility, have reflexively reached for explanations like these (or worse) despite having no relationship whatsoever to the accused.

I hope it goes without saying that if someone close to me were a victim of a crime like this, I would reflexively defend and support her. In a situation where everybody involved is a stranger to me, though, my response isn’t emotional, although it is a kind of second-nature reflex just by nature of having read about or heard about crimes like this so many times. I know the statistics. I know what my female friends and family members went through during their college years (which I suppose does make it emotional, to some extent). I know what frats are like. I immediately assume not only that the woman is telling the truth but that the men aren’t the only guilty parties, that they’re beneficiaries of a corrupt culture that abets and protects them.

What does it say that so many men instead react to this story as though the accused were all their brothers, their sons, their dear friends? Why do they feel so strongly that These nice boys wouldn’t do that? Why not reflexively think of the woman, equally a stranger, as their friend, their sister?

Some of these men, of course, are themselves rapists—some are rapists who know what they are, and want to stamp out any accountability for crimes like theirs; some are rapists who don’t believe that’s what they are, and are alarmed to find things that they themselves did when they were younger, and perhaps still do (coerce or trick or drug women into sex that isn’t what they think of as forcible rape but also isn’t in any sense consensual), now correctly described as rape. These men are scrambling to defend themselves more than they’re thinking about the accused. (I think this is what’s going on with a lot of the big names on Twitter and elsewhere in social media defending the accused or casting aspersions on the accuser.)

But there are a lot of men who are genuinely, if misguidedly, concerned for the accused, and for some broader idea of “justice” and, God help us, men’s rights. To some degree this is a consequence of decades of diligent far-right activism, the relentless promulgation of a fantasy narrative of totalitarian feminism and political correctness run amok. But that alone can’t explain it, and it certainly can’t excuse it. You can’t earnestly believe in a “war on men,” or believe that women receive disproportionate help and support in our society such that things need to be proactively counterbalanced to make things fairer for men, if you have any genuinely close relationships with women. Which suggests that none of these men do have such relationships. And whether it’s the misogynist attitude that precedes the inability or unwillingness to form those relationships or vice versa, it’s clearly of a piece with the fact that so many men see seven (or fifty-seven) strangers as their brothers and the woman those men abused as something less, or nothing at all.

If your reflexive response to hearing about or reading about this story was to feel sympathy for the men, to be concerned that they were being treated unjustly, to be indignant about their names being publicized, please reflect on that for a moment. Why are their feelings, or their treatment, or their good names more real to you, more important to you—why are they more human to you—than the woman they assaulted? What do they have that she lacks?

Friday, September 25, 2026

Fandom Is a Disease


Yes, this is one of those things where there's some online discourse that piques my interest (in this case, the conversation about whether it's bad, or how bad it is, to continue being a Harry Potter fan in light of J. K. Rowling's ongoing embrace of international supervillainy) but I don't get around to writing about it until weeks later when everybody else has moved on. In this case, I wasn't sure I should write about it at all, because my thesis is obnoxious and probably unconstructive, but whatever, it's fun, here we go.

And yes, “Fandom Is a Disease” is a needlessly provocative title. But still. Fandom isn't a terrible disease, in the big scheme of things. It's hardly ever terminal. But it is a disease, a disorder. At its usual worst, it's like leprosy used to be back in the bad old days, where nobody who doesn't also have it wants to interact with you and you end up living in a sad little colony of similarly afflicted outcasts. More often, it's like herpes is nowadays, where if you do a good and conscientious job of managing it, most people don't even need to know that you have it, although maybe you're still most comfortable in congress with other folks who do. Some people find community in their afflictions; some people even find merit in them. Tuberculosis used to be sexy. It made you fetchingly wan and enervated!

This metaphor, it should be clear, has legs. Fandom is contagious, it's sometimes debilitating, it can be embarrassing (particularly when sex is involved), some people are more susceptible to it than others, and it's generally curable but every now and then some poor soul gets a particularly stubborn case, maybe a drug-resistant strain, and just has to live with it forever. But for the most part, it comes and goes. Some people get recurring cases, or lifelong cases, often of rare and obscure conditions. Some people are prone to catching everything all the time. Most people catch something at least every once in a while—if you never catch anything, ever, you're probably living in a bubble. You need to get out more.

Like many people, especially people my age, I caught the Star Wars bug as a kid. It was ubiquitous back then, and there was no known treatment. I had a very grave case of it for many years. In my early teens, we got it under control for a while, but I had a serious flare-up when The Phantom Menace hit theaters. Thing is, at that point I was a little older, a little stronger, and the second epidemic strain was a lot weaker than the first. My immune system was up to the challenge. The prequel-trilogy relapse wasn't nearly as severe a case as my childhood bout with the original trilogy and the Expanded Universe, and in fact, when it eventually abated, I was thoroughly inoculated. I had a bit of a fever when The Force Awakens came out, but it broke quickly; I never even bothered watching The Rise of Skywalker. I was cured. (Do I still have fondness for Star Wars? Sure. Did I still watch, and love, Andor? Absolutely. But I enjoyed it for itself, on its own terms, rather than as a Star Wars fan.)

Harry Potter fandom is like conjunctivitis. It's normal enough for kids to get it, although it's still pretty gross; it's pretty weird to keep getting it as an adult. It's really weird to have it all the time. The chronic forms are absolutely treatable. There's no excuse for living with it for longer than a week. Yes, some kinds of conjunctivitis don't come from touching shit. But this one does. This is a case of pink eye that you keep getting via contact with shit from the world's most influential and committed transphobe. Grow up, wash your hands of her, and stop touching that shit.

Landsknecht Voran!